AMA — the Milton Friedman edition

Well, you have to admit that Milton Friedman was the nicest, most gentlemanly economist ever. Even when heckled by his student audience, his smile always accompanied his razor-sharp wit and wisdom. Here’s a sample:

Ask me anything. Maybe I’ll smile. Or maybe not.

Categories: AMA -- Ask me anything

18 replies

  1. Can you please give excerpts/examples from Niti Aayog’s India@75 strategy that you did not like? I saw your tweet and it seems you are mighty displeased with the strategy document.
    On a different note, is there a typo in the heading? It should be AMA, instead of AKA.


  2. Are you acquainted with the works of C K Raju?

    Liked by 1 person

    • I did not know about C.K.Raju. I checked the wiki page on him. It appears that he’s quite accomplished.


      • I saw his lecture on Mathematics vs Ganita where he states important things which aren’t in discussion or discourse even today. No popular scientist or mathematician that I have heard acknowledges what Raju is saying.
        Which makes me wonder if what he is saying is true or not.


        • Dear Keshav,

          I watched a few minutes of this lengthy lecture out of curiosity, and since it came without the attendant benefit of easy access to the accompanying slides, mostly at random. In all, I watched about 5 minutes of his talk. I think I do get a sense of the level at which he was speaking.

          If you would kind enough to compile a list of the things which he says and which you don’t understand, personally, then I guess I should be able to help. Coming to the truth question, I should also always be able to tell if something is true, to the best of my knowledge, or not. But the “not-known-true-to-me” category could very well include a wide spectrum of things—right from ignorance to the speaker’s glaring (objectively demonstrable) errors. So, there. … Somehow I feel sure that you wouldn’t pursue this project—not immediately, anyway.




        • I attempted to watch the video but the form put me off. He is hard to follow and he rambles. I don’t have the time to plod through it.


  3. Any tips for (literally) surviving in India, esp. in today’s India? Assume that a well-educated engineer (MTech (IIT), PhD (Engg.)) has raised this question.




    • To survive anywhere, not just in India, one has to create value. The fact is that we depend on what others produce. We get what they produce only by producing something that those others would be willing to take from us in exchange. Easier said than done.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. What are your thoughts on planned data-localization restrictions to be set by the Indian government on Googles, Facebooks etc?


  5. If somebody is willing to sell and somebody willing to buy, it should be allowed. Right?
    So if somebody wants to sell addictive-drugs and somebody wants to buy it (like heroin/brown-sugar) so be it.
    Are you comfortable with this idea of a free market for drugs?


    • Yes, all voluntary exchanges among consenting adults must be allowed, whether it be drugs or prostitution or labor. What matters is the agreement of the parties to a trade, not some third party. If you don’t like drugs, don’t buy or sell drugs, and don’t take drugs.

      Maybe that drugs are harmful to the user. Well, so what? If a person willingly harms himself, on what moral or ethical grounds is someone else justified in interfering with what a free person does?

      Milton Friedman had pointed out that if he know that a person was committing a “sin”, then he is morally obliged to stop the person from sinning. But — and that’s the bind — he said that he can never be so arrogant as to decide for another whether it is a sin or not. Basically he argued for epistemological modesty. Don’t assume that you know what is good or bad for another. If there are no victims from a particular act, then you have a moral obligation to not interfere in the act.



  1. Who Owns You? – Atanu Dey on India's Development

Leave a Reply. Comment may be held for moderation.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: